top of page
LangMitteOhne.png
Bildschirmfoto 2025-11-04 um 14.24.50.png
All about frozen seafood
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Xing
  • Youtube
Bildschirmfoto 2025-11-04 um 12.40.10.png

Whitefish in transition, or: It doesn't always have to be cod.

7 hours ago
8 min read

Cod is considered by many cuisines to be the epitome of classic white fish. Its light flesh, mild flavor, and versatility make it a staple on numerous menus. However, fluctuating availability and prices are prompting retailers and restaurants to take a closer look at other types of white fish. This isn't just about finding cheaper alternatives, but rather about determining which fish is best suited for which application.


Whether as fillets, loins, portions, fish cubes, or breaded products: white fish is one of the most important product groups in the international seafood trade. However, the term does not refer to a single fish species, but rather encompasses various species with light-colored flesh and a generally mild flavor.


Why cod can come under pressure

The total catch quota for Northeast Arctic cod from the Barents Sea is 285,000 tons in 2026 : 16 percent lower than in 2025 and the lowest it has been since 1991. For 2027, Norway and Russia agreed on October 23, 2026, to increase the quota to 325,000 tons. This is an increase of around 14 percent and the first increase in six years.


The increased quota continues to be met with weak offspring. According to the Norwegian Institute of Marine Research, the fishery depends heavily on the moderately strong 2021 year class. Only a small amount of additional offspring is expected in the spawning stock until 2028.


At the same time, suppliers are broadening their selection of whitefish. The MSC Nordic State of the Market Report 2026 shows that in Sweden, Denmark, Finland, and Norway, sales volumes of MSC-certified cod products fell by around 13 percent compared to the previous year during the reporting period of 2025/26. Alaska pollock increased by around 11 percent in this segment. The report describes how suppliers are responding to fluctuating availability and prices by offering a wider mix of species.


This presents a challenge for wholesalers, restaurants and catering companies: calculations must remain stable while product quality, portion size and availability must be guaranteed.


However, the search for alternatives doesn't necessarily mean completely replacing cod. Often, a broader approach makes more sense. Depending on the dish, other types of white fish can offer a functionally and gustatoryly convincing solution.

The crucial point is not just to look for a "replacement fish", but to consider the specific application.


Alaska pollock: versatile and easy to calculate costs

Alaska pollock is one of the largest whitefish species on the international market. Despite its German name, it does not belong to the salmon family, but to the cod family.

The flesh is light in color, lean, and mild in flavor. Due to its uniform texture, Alaska pollock is particularly well-suited for standardized applications. These include breaded products, fish fingers, portioned fillets, fish burgers, and catering dishes.

Its strength lies less in a particularly pronounced inherent flavor than in its versatility. Spices, sauces, and breadings combine well with its subtle taste.

For kitchens that process large quantities of uniform portion sizes, Alaska pollock can be an economically attractive option. However, the product form, glaze, block or individual freezing, and the actual fillet content should be taken into account when calculating costs.


Hake: mild, juicy and versatile

Hake from different fishing grounds is traded in varying qualities. Its white to slightly cream-colored flesh is mild and, if prepared properly, can remain pleasantly juicy.

Fillets and portions are suitable for stir-fries, oven dishes, sauces, and Mediterranean recipes. Hake also offers interesting possibilities for the restaurant industry because its flavor is easy to combine with other ingredients and is not too overpowering.

The quality can vary depending on the species, origin, fishing method, and processing. Therefore, hake should not be considered a uniform product. For a meaningful comparison, the exact specifications, fillet thickness, cut, and intended preparation are crucial.

Hake is therefore not simply a cheaper alternative to cod. It can occupy its own independent position on the menu – for example in Mediterranean fish dishes, curries, or as a pan-fried fillet portion.


Hoki fillet: mild in taste and delicate in texture

Hoki complements the selection of white fish with its light flesh and mild flavor. Its fillets have a rather delicate texture and easily fall apart into individual flakes when cooked. This makes it ideal for dishes where a succulent, finely flaky result is desired.

Hoki fillets can be prepared in the oven, steamed, or used in fish casseroles and fish pies. They are also suitable for breaded preparations. Due to their delicate texture, gentle handling and appropriate cooking time are important to ensure the fillets remain as a single portion.

When purchasing hoki, check the fillet size, bone structure, skin, glaze, and shrinkage during thawing and cooking. If hoki is intended to replace a compact cod loin fillet, pay particular attention to the desired portion size. Crucially, how well the specific cut and preparation method suit the product's characteristics is paramount.


Pollock: stronger and firmer

The saithe, sold commercially as saithe, has firmer and sometimes darker flesh than cod. Its flavor is somewhat stronger. This makes it suitable for dishes where the fish should remain noticeable even alongside more intense ingredients.

Pollock can be used in stir-fries, casseroles, fish cakes, soups, and strongly seasoned dishes. While not a direct substitute for cod in every recipe, it offers a unique culinary option.

Its texture can be particularly advantageous in dishes with tomatoes, mustard, herbs, or strong sauces. However, for especially light-colored, delicately presented fillet dishes, it's necessary to check whether the color and texture meet expectations.

Ling: firm flesh and similar in taste to cod [R6]

Ling has white, relatively firm flesh and tastes similar to cod. A subtle saltiness gives it a distinctive character without being overpowering in a dish. This makes it a good choice for kitchens that want to prepare familiar white fish dishes with a different type of fish.

Its fillets are suitable for frying, poaching, and steaming. A herb or mustard crust also complements its flavor. Due to its firm texture, ling can also be used as an ingredient in fish soups and stews, provided the cooking time is adjusted to the size of the pieces.

When preparing ling, the thickness and cut of the fillet should be the primary considerations. A thick back cut requires a different cooking time than a thinner fillet portion. Therefore, only a comparison of similar cuts and the actual serving sizes will reveal whether ling is an economically viable alternative.


Redfish: delicately nutty and versatile

Redfish brings light-colored flesh with a delicate, nutty, savory aroma to the plate. Its relatively firm texture and distinctive flavor make it interesting for dishes where the fish should remain recognizable alongside the side dishes and sauce.

Fillets can be cooked in a pan over low heat, baked in the oven, or used in casseroles and gratins. Steamed or poached, redfish also pairs well with herbs, lemon, and classic fish sauces. Gentle handling when turning helps to preserve the fillets.

For practical purposes in the kitchen, fillet weight, thickness, and whether it's prepared with or without skin are important. Depending on the product, these factors can result in different portion sizes and cooking times. Therefore, when comparing offers, the specific cut and yield should be considered, as well as the desired flavor.


Wolffish: delicate flavor and elastic, firm meat

Wolffish has light-colored, elastic, and firm flesh with a delicate, distinctive flavor. Its texture offers a noticeable bite, making it ideal for fillet dishes where a clearly defined portion of fish is the focus.

The fillets are suitable for gentle frying, poaching, and steaming. They can be combined with mustard sauce, braised cucumbers, or an herb crust, for example. Wolffish can also be used as a firm-fleshed addition to fish soups and stews. The cooking time should be adjusted to the thickness of the fillets or pieces of fish.

For a high-quality plated dish, uniform cuts and appropriate portion weights are particularly helpful. When calculating costs, in addition to the purchase price, the effort required for portioning and the final result after cooking must also be considered. Whether wolffish is the desired alternative therefore also depends on the expected texture on the plate.


Kingclip: mild aroma and firm white flesh

Kingclip fish has firm, white flesh with a mild, slightly sweet flavor. It combines a compact texture with a delicate aroma, making it ideal for dishes that require both a firm bite and a subtle flavor.

Fillets and portions are suitable for steaming, poaching, and oven cooking. Brief frying at a moderate heat is also possible. Kingclip can be combined with light herb sauces, but can also be used in more flavorful dishes such as a fish curry. Adjusting the cooking time to the cut helps to keep the meat moist.

When purchasing king clip, portion size, fillet thickness, and bone status should be checked. For a reliable comparison with cod, it is crucial how the specific product can be prepared and what the yield remains after cooking. King clip can thus establish its own distinct position on the menu.


Not every alternative works in every dish.

A cod loin for a high-quality plated dish has different requirements than a fish cube for a curry or a breaded fillet for catering.

Therefore, several questions should be answered when selecting a whitefish species:

  • Should the fish have a visible, uniform fillet structure?

  • Is it fried, steamed, deep-fried, or cooked in the oven?

  • Does it need to retain its shape in a sauce?

  • Do you prefer a neutral or a more pronounced flavor?

  • What portion size is needed?

  • What are the losses during defrosting and cooking?

  • Is individual withdrawal required?

  • What are the origin and certification requirements?


Only once these points have been clarified can it be assessed which fish species and cut are economically and culinarily sensible.


The product form is almost as important as the type of fish.

Not only the type of fish, but also its preparation influences the result. A compact back fillet (loin) behaves differently during cooking than a thin fillet. Fish cubes place different demands on shape stability and portion accuracy than a whole fillet side.

Individually frozen portions can be removed one at a time, reducing the risk of thawing more product than needed. Block-frozen products can be economical when processing large quantities, but offer less flexibility.

Glaze, skin, bonelessness, cut, and calibration also affect the actual effort required. Therefore, two offers of the same fish species can yield very different results in practice.

As with shrimp, the advertised price per kilogram is only one part of the calculation. The cost per usable portion and the result after preparation are more meaningful.


Environmental certification must be considered in relation to the product.

The environmental assessment of a fish product depends on factors including fishing area, stock development, fishing method, fishery management, and supply chain. The fish species alone is not a sufficient basis for this assessment.

Whether a fish product meets the requirements of a recognized environmental certification cannot be determined solely from the species. The decisive factor is the specific certified fishery. The traceability of certified goods is further ensured along the supply chain.

Statements regarding origin and certification should therefore always refer to the specific product. Blanket assessments of an entire fish species do not do justice to the differences between fishing areas, stocks, and fisheries.


From replacement logic to application logic

The discussion about alternative whitefish species is often driven by price. This is understandable, but it's too simplistic. A fish can be cheaper to buy but still incur higher costs if it loses more weight, is more difficult to portion, or isn't suitable for the intended preparation.

Conversely, a higher purchase price can be economically advantageous if the portions are uniform, there is little cooking loss, and the workload is reduced.

For KANZOW, therefore, an application-oriented approach is paramount: not every whitefish species has to imitate cod. What matters is which properties are required for the specific dish, the cooking process, and the cost calculation.

This perspective also opens up culinary opportunities. Hoki, hake, Alaska pollock, saithe, ling, redfish, wolffish, and kingclip don't have to be seen solely as substitutes. Used correctly, they can expand a product range and cover different taste and price segments.


Conclusion: More diversity creates room for maneuver

Cod remains an important and versatile food fish. At the same time, it is worthwhile to consider a broader selection of white fish. Different species, cuts, and processing methods allow for a more precise response to applications, availability, and cost requirements.

The crucial question is therefore not: "Which fish is the cheapest substitute for cod?" A more meaningful question is: "Which white fish delivers the best result for this dish?"


Those who consider taste, structure, yield, processing and origin together can make a more informed decision – and turn a supposed alternative into an independent culinary solution.

Comments


bottom of page